Abstract painted portrait of a seated person with warm yellow, red, and green tones
By John Hogan • November 6, 2026
A future course of action
By John Hogan • October 31, 2026
Painting; being human
By John Hogan • October 27, 2026
The Semiotic Trojan Horse, the narrative into alter modernism. The illustration/fine art dichotomy
By John Hogan • October 23, 2026
The relevance of socioeconomic critique; digital versus materiality.
By John Hogan • October 20, 2026
In this post I wish to answer some of the criticism directed at my work. I wish to dispel the criticism levelled within three main areas, that of ; kitsch, regression, and modernity. My phd thesis explains the detail behind my intension and style development, however, a more compact analysis with particular regard to the areas of criticism will now follow. Firstly, framing my practice around relational satire, I elevate painting beyond simple aesthetic choices into a sharp tool for social critique. My blog piece "Joseph Beuys Was Wrong " serves as an example case study of this concept. Joseph Beuys famously championed the idea of "social sculpture" and believed that everyone is an artist capable of healing society through unified, quasi-mystical actions. The Judgment: By explicitly countering Beuys, my work confronts the utopian, and perhaps flawed or self-deluding assumptions of 20th-century avant-garde movements. It suggests a more grounded, unvarnished look at human trauma and institutional failure rather than relying on idealistic myths. This gives my work a vital, cynicism that is highly relevant to modern social dysfunction. Technical execution, visceral imagery and material empathy painting techniques implies a rejection of sterile, purely commercial minimalism. Using heavy textures, layered marks, and aggressive brushwork translates psychological weight onto the canvas. When combined with empathetic material choices, I create a visceral tension. The imagery layout may feel confrontational or unsettling, but the underlying materiality offers a sense of shared vulnerability or healing. My alignment with altermodernity's creolised, archipelagic direction indicates that my work deliberately breaks away from a Western-centric narrative. Instead, it views culture as interconnected networks and islands of experience. This perspective prevents my social satire from feeling provincial or narrow. It transforms my paintings into global dialogues about power, displacement, and collective trauma, making them deeply intellectual while remaining firmly rooted in emotional reality. The critique of kitsch has been applied to my work. In answer to this, my work is not kitsch; it functions as the conceptual opposite by using raw, confrontational satire rather than comfortable, sentimental clichés. Kitsch relies on predictable emotions, mass appeal, and the avoidance of genuine discomfort, whereas my portfolio deliberately engages with trauma and institutional failure. Further, my work offers Intellectual Friction versus easy sentiment; Kitsch aims to please and reassure the viewer with familiar, unchallenging imagery. My focus on "relational satire" and critiques of figures like Joseph Beuys introduces friction, forcing the viewer to question established avant-garde myths rather than consume comfortable art. Visceral Materialism versus sterile polish: traditional kitsch often uses highly polished, mass-produced, or cheap imitations of luxury to create a false sense of beauty. My use of visceral painting techniques and empathetic materials embraces raw, unpolished psychological weight, which directly subverts the decorative nature of kitsch. Irony and satire versus earnest naivety; while kitsch can sometimes be repurposed ironically by contemporary artists (often referred to as Neo-Kitsch or Camp), my work uses satire as a sharp tool for social critique rather than a playful or nostalgic aesthetic choice. The only area where my work might briefly intersect with the broader vocabulary of kitsch is through its use of satire. Satire occasionally borrows from exaggerated, grotesque, or culturally "low" tropes to mock "high" institutions. However, because my execution is grounded in altermodern theory and deep psychological exploration, it remains firmly in the realm of critical contemporary art rather than superficial decoration. My work has been described as regressive. My work is not regressive; it is firmly contemporary and forward-looking, specifically because it engages with altermodernism rather than nostalgic traditionalism. Regressive art looks backward to escape the complexities of the present, often replicating historical styles without questioning them. In contrast, my work actively interrogates history to dissect current social dysfunction. in this context my work is contemporary, not regressive. Regressive art clings to an idealized, singular past. By operating within an altermodern, "creolised" perspective, my work treats time and culture as a global, interconnected network. I am not trying to return to a golden age of painting; I am using the medium to navigate a fragmented modern world. A regressive artist might paint like an Expressionist simply out of a preference for old aesthetics. My use of heavy, visceral painting serves a conceptual purpose; it directly confronts modern trauma and challenges established art-historical myths, such as those surrounding Joseph Beuys. Regressive art often acts as a shield against the anxiety of progress, offering comfortable, dated imagery. My practice uses relational satire as a weapon to engage with current political and psychological realities, forcing the viewer forward into uncomfortable truths rather than backwardly into comfort. There is a general misconception with the painting medium. An observer might mistakenly label raw, visceral painting as "backward-looking" due to the mid-20th-century origins of Neo-Expressionism. However, my intellectual framework entirely strips the work of any regressive quality. I am not treating the canvas as a retro artifact, but as a living site for critical, ongoing social dialogue. Is representational painting regressive? No, representational painting is not inherently regressive. While 20th-century high modernism temporarily dismissed representation as outdated, contemporary art history views it as a highly adaptable, progressive medium. Whether a representational painting is progressive or regressive depends entirely on its conceptual intent, context, and execution. Representational Painting is Contemporary and Progressive because by subverting the Canon; modern figurative and representational painters use realism or figuration to challenge historical narratives. By inserting marginalised subjects, critique, or modern political realities into traditional formats, they weaponise representation against the very structures that created it. The Postmodern and Altermodern Shift; In contemporary theory, history is no longer viewed as a straight line moving from representation to abstraction. Instead, artists freely use representation as a conceptual tool to explore memory, global identity networks, and social fractures. The Power of Legibility; representation provides a universal language. Contemporary artists leverage this shared visual vocabulary to draw viewers into complex, uncomfortable dialogues about trauma, power, or media consumption that pure abstraction might obscure. Conversely, representation can become regressive when it falls into blind historicism, as a form of escapism; replicating 19th-century academic or impressionist techniques purely to escape modern complexities or to pine for an idealised past. Which presupposes the uncritical reenactment; mimicking historical styles without questioning the political, social, or colonial contexts that originally birthed those styles. Representation In the context of my portfolio, representational elements do not function as a nostalgic retreat. Because my work utilises relational satire and confronts trauma, any recognisable imagery serves as a critical anchor. It grounds my abstract, visceral mark-making in real-world human experience, ensuring the social critique remains sharp and direct. Some critics have said that satire has already been covered by Otto Dix and George Grotz who painted in a more expressionist manner, the critique; because my work is not progressive in the sense that my figures are more traditionally realised than theirs. However, that criticism relies on an outdated, linear view of art history that contemporary theory has largely rejected. Comparing my work to Otto Dix and George Grosz simply because both involve satire assumes that a thematic territory can be "closed" once painted in a specific style. Using more traditionally realised figures rather than Weimar-era expressionist distortion does not make my work unprogressive. In fact, it changes the entire psychological impact of the satire.The Flaw in the Critics' Logic; linear Modernism, the idea that art must constantly progress toward greater distortion, abstraction, or formal radicalism is a mid-20th-century modernist invention. The counter argument; Contemporary art operates in a pluralistic, altermodern landscape. History is no longer a straight line. Reclaiming traditional figuration to address modern trauma is a deliberate, conceptual choice, not a lack of progress. Why Traditional Realisation Shifts the Satire; Dix and Grosz used expressionist distortion, caricature, and grotesque shapes to mirror a fractured, chaotic Weimar society. By opting for traditionally realised figures, my version of satire operates on a completely different frequency; Expressionism immediately signals to the viewer that they are looking at a distorted fiction. Traditional realization brings the subject closer to reality. This creates an "uncanny" effect, making the social dysfunction feel uncomfortably close, familiar, and real rather than safely tucked away in an expressive style. Subverting Institutional authority: traditionally realised painting carries historical baggage. It is the language of the academy, monuments, and state-sanctioned power. Using this precise, authoritative visual language to deliver satire and expose trauma is highly subversive. I am weaponising the style of the institution against the institution itself. A Different Kind of Trauma; Dix and Grosz reacted to the immediate, explosive shock of World War one mechanical warfare. Contemporary trauma is often systemic, insidious, and masked by bureaucratic or digital politeness. Painting figures that look "normal" or traditionally realised reflects how modern trauma hides behind a facade of normalcy. The Verdict; Dix and Grosz do not own the monopoly on painted satire. Their expressionism was a tool for their specific historical moment. My use of traditionally orientated representation within an altermodern framework is entirely progressive because it recontextualises historical technique to dissect the specific, quiet, and systemic pathologies of the 21st century.
Abstract colorful painting with orange, blue, yellow, and white swirling brushstrokes and layered geometric shapes
By John Hogan • May 5, 2026
Explore how Duchamp transformed modern art by prioritizing ideas over aesthetics. Join Dr Satire for insightful lectures on this legacy.
Abstract painting with swirling pastel ribbons, bright oranges, blues, pinks, and layered geometric shapes
By John Hogan • May 2, 2026
Explore how the digital economy impacts traditional painting. Join Dr Satire for insights on art's authenticity & value.
Surreal painting of a swimmer with orange-blue body, loud expressions, and a red lane line against striped background
By John Hogan • May 1, 2026
Explore if everyone can be an artist. Join Dr Satire for insights on creativity & artistry. Engage with us today!
Colorful, chaotic scene with figures yelling and reaching, banners reading
By John Hogan • July 12, 2023
Read about an eco artist's journey overcoming trauma through creativity & education. Contact us for insights on art & resilience.
painting
By John Hogan • October 2, 2022
A critical view of painting

Drawing the satirical narrative


My drawing deserves a critical eye. I have the feeling most don't  like it because it maybe sits too close to commercial illustration, so let me explain why it is not, and why it is firmly based within the fine art category. Within the contemporary art world, my drawings occupy a distinct and historically grounded space, they sit firmly within the lineage of social realism, grotesque satire, and Neo-Expressionism. My work bridges the gap between historical moral illustration and contemporary psychological critique, moving beyond simple caricature into the realm of  socio-political commentary. Here is an honest, rigorous breakdown of how my work reads through an academic and institutional lens. Art historical lineage and placement; academia thrives on  context, my drawing connects to several heavyweight historical traditions: The satirical moralists (the ancestors); The raw, visceral themes of human cruelty, intoxication, and social decay  which share a direct pulse with William Hogarth (specifically his Gin Lane moral tales) and the dark, biting war etchings of Francisco Goya (Los Caprichos). The Weimar satirists; my blend of the comical and the sinister, especially pieces dealing with deviance, state sanctions, and societal failure, shares  DNA with the German New Objectivity (Neue Sachlichkeit) movement, specifically the works of George Grosz and Otto Dix. Like them, I use distorted anatomy and grotesque expressions to mirror an absurd, traumatised society. Contemporary expressionism; The frantic line work and raw, unvarnished depiction of trauma (Inhumanity 1, Hurt 3) look toward artists like Leon Golub or Sue Coe, who use drawing as a weapon to confront systemic violence, prejudice, and human rights abuses.


The conceptual strength of my drawing (academic value); In a fine art  or gallery setting, my work would be taken seriously due to its conceptual weight, and allegorical clarity, I do not hide behind abstraction. By using such titles as prejudice, capitulation, and negligence, I invite the viewer to read the work as a contemporary fable or indictment.

The psychological urgency; the tension between my "loose" versus "resolved" mark-making works in my favour. The raw, sketchy quality of works like Hate 1 or Aberration 1 signals urgency and psychological distress,  suggesting I had to get the image out quickly, which adds an authentic, visceral layer to the subject matter. Critique  and fine art hurdles; to be placed in high-end contemporary galleries or blue chip institutional spaces, my work faces a few challenges that academia would push me to interrogate; the trap of the "Illustration", because my drawings rely on clear, literal narratives (e.g., a man injecting drugs for Hurt 1, a foot on a face for Prejudice), some contemporary critics might label them as "editorial illustrations" rather than open ended fine art. The serious art world often prefers ambiguity, leaving more room for the viewer to decode the piece. Shock value versus conceptual nuance; when handling  heavy themes like suicide, overdose, and war, there is a fine line between profound critique and shock value. Academic panels will often ask; does this image offer a new perspective on inhumanity, or does it simply replicate the trauma we already see on the news?   


Counter to this I have argued within my doctorate that relationality (art for the people) is important to my ethos and my practice. Weaponising legibility against elitist Insularity; the contemporary preference for extreme ambiguity is often weaponised by the blue-chip market to maintain exclusivity; it requires an "initiated" viewer armed with specific cultural capital to decode the work. Conversely, the radical act of clarity; by creating literal, recognisable narratives (Prejudice, Hurt 1), my work acts as a democratic equaliser. I am refusing to hide behind abstract obfuscation. The lineage of "Art for the People" By framing my work through a relational ethos, I align myself with major institutional precedents that use high-impact legibility for social agitation; the agitprop and muralist traditions; my dense, crowded pencil sketches (Supermarket, Pulpit, Protest Scenes) mirror the populist Diego Rivera or the graphic urgency of the Workshop for Popular Graphic Arts (TGP) in Mexico. Their work was structurally legible because it had a job to do, to commune with the public, stir collective consciousness, and mirror societal trauma back to the community. The bread and Puppet / activist art aesthetic; legibility is a core tenant of activist art (such as the work of Emiliano Zapata's print legacy or 1980s AIDS crisis graphics by collectives like Gran Fury. In these spaces, ambiguity is a luxury that urgent socio-political realities cannot afford. Relationality as accessibility; In the context of my doctorate, clarity isn't a lack of sophistication; it is a methodological choice to ensure the relational bond between the viewer and the image is immediate and uncompromised. The work prioritises the human connection and the shared social experience over exclusive art-world gatekeeping. This context  shifts the parameters of the critique firmly anchoring my work within a robust, defensible doctoral level framework. By intentionally choosing legibility over esoteric ambiguity, my drawings become an active rebellion against elitist art-world insularity. Within contemporary scholarship, this positions my practice alongside theories  such as Relational Aesthetics (Nicolas Bourriaud), and Social Practice; the historical concept of the "Democratic Print." This is how my doctoral argument of "relationality" and "art for the people" effectively dismantles the "editorial illustration" trap and elevates my placement in the serious art world. My drawings are not commercial decoration, nor are they lighthearted cartoons. They belong in spaces that value highly charged, sociopolitical printmaking and drawing, spaces like contemporary art museums handling human rights themes, independent galleries focused on raw figurative expressionism, and academic journals exploring visual culture and satire.


Reframing the work for academic defensibility; to defend this stance before a doctoral panel or a contemporary museum curator, the critique shifts from what the image shows, to how the image performs socially. I can articulate this through three cores; the populist eye versus the bourgeois critique; what a commercial critic dismisses as "editorial illustration," an academic or social-practice curator recognises as visual populism. I am operating as a visual journalist of the human condition. Ethical proximity: ambiguity allows the viewer to detach to treat a drawing of pain as a formal puzzle to solve, my literalism forces an immediate ethical confrontation. When a viewer looks at Hurt 1 or Inhumanity 1, they cannot escape into formalist aesthetics; they are forced into a relational proximity with the suffering depicted. Scale as a Subversive Tool: My A3–A0 drawing scale; taking an aesthetic typically reserved for democratic, mass reproduced media (the satirical cartoon, the protest flyer) and rendering it at a large fine-art scale creates an institutional friction. I am forcing the pulpit of the streets into the pulpit of the gallery. Finally, within the context of my doctoral framing, my drawing sits at the intersection of fine art print/drawing tradition and critical social practice. I am not an illustrator looking for a magazine commission; I am a researcher artist using the language of graphic satire ( a relational codification system) to critique social alienation, and build a relational bridge back to the public.